| 125 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | James Nicholson (D 5-3) | ODU - Unat | | 2. | Jarrod Garnett | Virginia Tech | | 3. | Ty Mitch | VTech - Unat | |
| 133 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Devin Carter (MD 11-3) | Virginia Tech | | 2. | Kyle Hutter | Old Dominion | | 3. | Tyler Small | Kent St - Unat | |
| 141 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Chris Diaz (D 3-1) | Virginia Tech | | 2. | Zach Neibert | Virginia Tech | | 3. | Germane Lindsey | Ohio University | |
| 149 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Ivan Lopouchanski (D 9-4) | UNCG - Unat | | 2. | Brian Stephens | Virginia Tech | | 3. | Nate Carr | Iowa State | |
| 157 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Pete Yates (FF) | Virginia Tech | | 2. | Jesse Dong | VTech - Unat | | 3. | Matt Cathell | Kent St - Unat | |
| 165 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Kyle Blevins ((FF) | Appalachian State | | 2. | Josh Shileds | Mercyhurst | | 3. | Matt Epperly | Virginia Tech | |
| 174 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Jon Reader (Fall 3:40) | Iowa State | | 2. | Byron Sigmon | UNCG - Unat | | 3. | Tristan Warner | ODU - Unat | |
| 184 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Tommy Spellman (D 9-2) | Virginia Tech | | 2. | Antonio Giorgio | UNC - Unat | | 3. | Jason McCroskey | UT - Chattanooga | |
| 197 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Dustin Kilgore (D 9-7) | Kent St - Unat | | 2. | Jerome Ward | Iowa State | | 3. | Erik Schuth | Ohio University | |
| 285 Top 3 Individuals |
| | Name | School | | 1. | Matt Gibson (D 11-8) | Iowa State | | 2. | Dave Marone | Virginia Tech | | 3. | Jeremy Johnson | Ohio University | |
